Elmsword
← Fitness

Fitness · Research · 4 min read

Cluster sets vs traditional sets: similar muscle growth when effort matches

A 2025 within-participant trial matched sets, reps, and RIR. Cluster sets and traditional sets produced similar gains in lean mass and muscle thickness.

The short version

Cluster sets (CS) break one set into short blocks with brief rests inside the set. Traditional sets (TS) do the reps without those breaks. A 2025 trial in European Journal of Applied Physiology compared the two in trained lifters, matching sets, repetitions, and effort with repetitions in reserve (RIR).

After the 8-week program, both legs grew. Thigh lean tissue mass rose by 171.8 g with CS and 201.1 g with TS. Rectus femoris thickness rose by 0.24 cm with CS and 0.17 cm with TS. The time × condition interactions were not significant (lean mass p = 0.272; thickness p = 0.297; Results, Fig. 3).

“…one limb performed a TS protocol and the contralateral limb performed 3 clusters of 4 repetitions with a 20-s intra-set rest period of the same exercises (CS).”

Vargas-Molina et al. · Abstract · full text

What the researchers did

Ten resistance-trained adults (7 men, 3 women; mean age 21.0 ± 1.5 years) finished the study. Each person trained both legs: one with traditional sets, the other with cluster sets. Sessions ran twice a week across an 8-week program. Exercises were single-leg leg press and leg extension, 5 sets of 12 repetitions each.

The CS leg used 3 clusters of 4 repetitions with a 20-s intra-set rest. Both legs rested 3 minutes between sets. Loads were adjusted so each traditional set and each cluster finished at 0–1 RIR. Outcomes were thigh lean tissue mass (DXA) and rectus femoris muscle thickness (ultrasound at mid-thigh). Strength was not measured.

Key findings

Cluster sets (CS) vs traditional sets (TS): post-training changes
OutcomeCSTSTime × condition pLocation
Thigh lean tissue mass (change)+171.8 g+201.1 g0.272Fig. 3A
Rectus femoris thickness (change)+0.24 cm+0.17 cm0.297Fig. 3B
Source: Vargas-Molina et al. 2025, Results and Fig. 3, 8-week program · Full text (PMC)
Bar chart: lean mass CS +171.8 g vs TS +201.1 g; thickness CS +0.24 cm vs TS +0.17 cm
Values from Results and Fig. 3 of Vargas-Molina et al. Black bars are cluster sets; grey bars are traditional sets.

“In conclusion, when sets, repetitions, and load adjustments were equalized based on RIR, a CS protocol elicits similar increases in muscle thickness and lean mass compared to a TS protocol.”

Vargas-Molina et al. · Abstract, Conclusion · full text

“We hypothesized that by matching total volume and effort levels (same number of RIR), CS would elicit greater hypertrophy than TS.”

Vargas-Molina et al. · Introduction · full text

“Alternatively, CS did not induce greater muscular gains compared to traditional training.”

Vargas-Molina et al. · Discussion · full text

How to read the result

The authors expected CS to grow more muscle when volume and effort were matched. That did not happen. Gains were similar, and total weekly training volume did not differ between conditions for either exercise.

“The findings also revealed no statistically significant differences in total weekly training volume between the CS and TS conditions for the leg press and leg extension exercises.”

Vargas-Molina et al. · Conclusions · full text

Effect sizes for lean mass were small (CS ES = 0.11; TS ES = 0.13). For muscle thickness they were larger (CS ES = 0.56; TS ES = 0.42; Abstract). Ultrasound reliability was high (ICC = 0.970, SEM = 3.63%).

Limitations

Only 10 people finished, all young and already trained, on two lower-body machine exercises across an 8-week program. “Similar” here is not an equivalence test. Muscle thickness was measured at one site on one muscle. DXA lean mass can shift with fluid. The authors note that clusters at 0–1 RIR “may increase the risk of injury in older participants.” The paper’s keywords list “Drop sets,” but this trial did not test drop sets.

“Finally, the study sample consisted of individuals who were homogeneous in terms of age and training experience.”

Vargas-Molina et al. · Limitations · full text

How to apply it

If you like short rests inside a set, this trial does not show an extra hypertrophy edge over traditional sets when sets, reps, and RIR are matched. If you prefer continuous sets, those produced similar lean-mass and thickness gains here.

This is my opinion, not advice: on this evidence, I would not switch to cluster sets just to grow more muscle under a matched prescription.

Sources

Source: Vargas-Molina et al., Eur J Appl Physiol 2025; 8-week program. DOI 10.1007/s00421-025-05712-6.

  1. StudyVargas-Molina S, García-Sillero M, Maroto-Izquierdo S, Baz-Valle E, Bautista-Mayorga B, Murri M, Schoenfeld BJ, Benítez-Porres J. Cluster sets and traditional sets elicit similar muscular hypertrophy: a volume and effort-matched study in resistance-trained individuals. European Journal of Applied Physiology. 2025;125(6):1725–1734.
    DOI: 10.1007/s00421-025-05712-6 · Full text (PMC) · Publisher full text (CC BY 4.0)

This article explains research for education. It isn't medical advice.