Elmsword
← Fitness

Fitness · Research · 2 min read

Different loads, similar observed muscle growth

A within-person trial compared lower and higher repetition ranges taken to volitional fatigue. The observed muscle-size changes were similar, with no clear between-condition difference.

What the researchers did

Twenty healthy young untrained men trained for ten weeks, three sessions/week. Limbs were randomly assigned to 8–12 versus 20–25 repetitions, using unilateral knee extensions and dumbbell preacher curls with three sets to volitional fatigue. The same person contributed to both conditions.

Key findings

Key findings
Muscle8–12 mean Δ (cm²)SD (cm²)20–25 mean Δ (cm²)SD (cm²)Comparison
Biceps1.200.921.390.98p=.518
Vastus lateralis0.692.730.752.43p=.932
Source: Lees et al. Table 3 · Study source
Different loads, similar observed muscle growth
Ultrasound CSA changes; means only; SD is reported separately in the table. Lees et al.

“Each set was separated by 90 s of rest”

Lees et al. · training methods

How to read the result

These are changes in cross-sectional area, not differences between conditions. The SD columns describe variation in group changes; they are not confidence intervals.

Limitations

Rest was held as part of the protocol, not experimentally compared, so the quoted rest duration is not evidence of an optimal interval. Participants were untrained young men, and the nonsignificant differences (p=.518 and p=.932) do not prove the loads have identical effects.

How to apply it

Choose a load and repetition range that lets you perform the exercise consistently and train with deliberate effort. This paper supports options rather than a uniquely best repetition band.

Sources

  1. StudyLees MJ, Mcleod JC, Morton RW, Currier BS, Fliss MD, McKellar SR, Sidhu RS, Stansfield BN, Webb EK, McGlory C, Burniston JG, Phillips SM. Resistance training load does not determine resistance training-induced hypertrophy across upper and lower limbs in healthy young males.
    DOI: 10.1113/JP289684 · PubMed abstract · Full text (Wiley)

This article explains research for educational use.