Fitness · Research · 6 min read
Nordic hamstring vs lengthened state eccentric training: hamstrings growth followed the exercise
A 2024 MSSE trial in 42 untrained young men compared 12 weeks of Nordic hamstring training with lengthened state eccentric training on a seated leg curl. Total knee flexor growth was similar, but which muscles grew depended on the exercise.
The short version
The Nordic hamstring exercise is mostly a body-weight move. You kneel with your ankles held in place (in this study, by straps) and lower your upper body forward under control. The hamstrings work while they lengthen, which is eccentric work.
A 2024 study in Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise compared it with lengthened state eccentric training (LSET): a seated leg curl machine set so the hip stayed bent at 120°, with the weight lowered slowly on one leg. Both programs grew the knee flexors by a similar total amount (+17% LSET, +14% NHT; P = 0.095). The difference was where the growth showed up.
The leg curl group grew the biceps femoris long head (BFlh) by 19% and the semimembranosus (SM) by 14%. The Nordic group grew BFlh by 5%, and SM didn't change significantly. The Nordic group grew the biceps femoris short head (BFsh) more: +22% versus +6%.
“Overall hamstring volume change was different between all three groups (LSET > NHT > CON; both P < 0.001; Fig. 2).”
Maeo et al. · Results · full text
What the researchers did
48 healthy young males with no systematic exercise training in the previous 18 months enrolled, and 42 finished, 14 per group. They were first assigned to the control group (CON) or to training based on schedule availability. Only the split between the two training groups was random.
Both training groups did 34 supervised sessions over 12 weeks. The number of eccentric sets per leg went from 2 to 4, and eccentric reps per set from 6 to 10. In LSET, participants lifted the load with both legs and lowered it with one leg over about 4 s, on a seated leg curl with a modified backrest that held the hip at 120° of flexion. In NHT, participants did the Nordic hamstring exercise; once they could control the descent to within 15° of horizontal, a weighted vest added load.
Before and after, MRI measured the volume of seven knee flexor muscles. The team also measured the BFlh aponeurosis (a sheet of tendon tissue inside the muscle) and knee flexion strength.
Key findings
| Outcome | LSET | NHT | CON | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BFlh volume (cm³) | 189 → 224 (+19%) | 200 → 211 (+5%) | 184 → 185 | Table 1; Results |
| SM volume (cm³) | 237 → 270 (+14%) | 248 → 252 (no significant change, P = 0.423) | 236 → 239 | Table 1; Results |
| ST volume (cm³) | 202 → 257 (+27%) | 227 → 273 (+20%) | 206 → 201 | Table 1; Results |
| BFsh volume (cm³) | 108 → 115 (+6%) | 103 → 126 (+22%) | 106 → 105 | Table 1; Results |
| KF and HE (BFlh + ST + SM) | +20% | +9% | No within-group change | Results |
| KF not HE (BFsh + GRA + SAR + POP) | +11% | +22% | No within-group change | Results |
| Overall hamstrings | +18% | +11% | No within-group change | Results |
| Overall knee flexors | +17% | +14% | No within-group change | Results (LSET vs NHT P = 0.095) |
| Maximum eccentric torque | +17% | +11% | +4% | Abstract; Table 2 (only LSET vs CON differed, P = 0.009) |
| BFlh aponeurosis area | +9% | +3% | +2% | Results; Table 1 |
| Source: Maeo et al. 2024, Table 1, Table 2, Results and Abstract; volumes are Pre → Post means · Full text (PMC) | ||||
How to read the result
The paper groups the muscles by job. BFlh, ST and SM bend the knee and also extend the hip (KF and HE). BFsh, gracilis (GRA), sartorius (SAR) and popliteus (POP) bend the knee but don't extend the hip (KF not HE). The leg curl at a bent hip grew the first group 2.2-fold more than NHT. NHT grew the second group 1.9-fold more than LSET.
“Interestingly, NHT resulted in no/small hypertrophy of the BFlh and SM (similar to CON and <LSET) but clear hypertrophy of the ST and BFsh (>CON, and similar or >LSET, respectively).”
Maeo et al. · Discussion · full text
Both exercises bend the knee. Even so, the pattern of growth across the muscles was different.
“In accordance with Maeo et al. (15,20), this suggests that exercise selection can markedly affect the morphological changes with resistance training even when exercises involve the same joint action.”
Maeo et al. · Discussion · full text
Strength was closer. Maximum eccentric torque rose 17% with LSET and 11% with NHT. Only LSET differed from CON, and the two training groups didn't differ from each other.
“Although only LSET increased eccentric strength compared with CON, there was no significant difference between LSET and NHT.”
Maeo et al. · Discussion · full text
What this doesn't tell us
The two programs differed in several ways at once: machine versus mostly body weight, hip bent versus hip straight, one-leg versus two-leg lowering, and a lifting phase that only LSET had. The authors say so directly.
“Therefore, this study did not isolate a single experimental variable; rather, it compared two quite distinct training regimes.”
Maeo et al. · Discussion · full text
The control group wasn't randomized; it was set by who could come to the lab two to three times a week. Three control participants' MRI scans were excluded, so CON had 11 people for muscle volume. The sample was healthy, untrained young men, so the results may not carry over to women, older adults or experienced lifters. The leg curl machine had a modified backrest, so a standard seated leg curl may not set the hip the same way. The study measured muscle size and strength; it did not measure sprinting or injuries.
How to apply it
If you want bigger hamstrings and you only train them with the Nordic hamstring exercise, this study suggests BFlh and SM may get little of the growth. In this trial, a seated leg curl with the hip bent grew those two muscles more. If you already do seated leg curls, note that the Nordic group grew BFsh more (+22% versus +6%), while ST growth didn't differ significantly between the two groups (P = 0.072).
Both programs started at 2 sets of 6 lowering reps per leg and built up over 12 weeks. If you have hamstring pain or an injury, this article isn't guidance for that; talk to a qualified professional.
Sources
Source: Maeo et al., Med Sci Sports Exerc 2024; 12-week program. DOI 10.1249/MSS.0000000000003490.
- StudyMaeo S, Balshaw TG, Nin DZ, Mc Dermott EJ, Osborne T, Cooper NB, Massey GJ, Kong PW, Pain MTG, Folland JP. Hamstrings Hypertrophy Is Specific to the Training Exercise: Nordic Hamstring versus Lengthened State Eccentric Training. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise. 2024;56(10):1893–1905.
DOI: 10.1249/MSS.0000000000003490 · Full text (PMC, CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)
This article explains research for education. It isn't medical advice.
