Elmsword
← Fitness

Fitness · Research · 6 min read

Rest between sets: more than 60 seconds showed a small edge for muscle growth

A 2024 Bayesian meta-analysis pooled 9 randomized studies on rest between sets. Muscle grew with short and longer rests, and rests longer than 60 s showed a small edge for arm and thigh growth.

The short version

A 2024 systematic review with Bayesian meta-analysis in Frontiers in Sports and Active Living looked at rest between sets and muscle size. The authors pooled the randomized studies they found that changed only the inter-set rest interval and measured muscle growth.

People grew muscle with both short and longer rests. When the authors compared longer rests (>60 s) with short rests (≤60 s) directly, the central estimates leaned toward longer rest for the thigh (SMD 0.17) and the arm (SMD 0.13). The whole-body estimate sat close to zero and slightly favored short rest (SMD −0.08). Every one of those 95% credible intervals (CrI) crosses zero.

“When subanalyzing the effects of rest interval length on hypertrophy of the upper and lower limbs, the results suggest a small benefit for rest intervals >60 s.”

Singer et al. · Discussion, Sub-analysis of body regions · full text

What the researchers did

The team searched PubMed/MEDLINE, Scopus, and Web of Science. They screened 359 studies, found 11 that might fit, and excluded 2 after reading the full texts. That left 9 randomized studies with 19 measurements: 10 thigh, 6 arm, and 3 whole body.

Eight studies tested young adults (18–35 years) and 1 tested older men (>65 years). Six used untrained participants and 3 used resistance-trained participants. Six studies were men only, 1 was women only, 1 included both, and 1 did not specify sex. The studies ran 5 to 10 weeks.

Rest was grouped two ways. The binary split was short (≤60 s) vs longer (>60 s). The four-category split was short (≤60 s), intermediate (61–119 s), long (120–179 s), and very long (≥180 s). Effects were standardized mean differences (SMDs). The paper pooled muscle growth only. It did not meta-analyze strength.

Key findings

Longer (>60 s) vs short (≤60 s) rest: controlled effect sizes (positive values favor longer rest)
ComparisonSMD (95% CrI)Probability > 0Probability > smallLocation
Arm0.13 (−0.27 to 0.51)0.740.45Fig. 4
Thigh0.17 (−0.13 to 0.43)0.880.54Fig. 5
Whole body−0.08 (−0.45 to 0.29)0.69 (favoring short)0.36 (favoring short)Fig. 6
Thigh, very long (≥180 s) vs short, network meta-analysis0.32 (−0.10 to 0.68)––Table 2
Source: Singer et al. 2024, Results, Figs. 4–6 and Table 2 · Full text (PMC)
Forest plot of longer vs short rest: arm 0.13 (−0.27 to 0.51), thigh 0.17 (−0.13 to 0.43), whole body −0.08 (−0.45 to 0.29)
Source: Results and Figs. 4–6 of Singer et al. Dots are central estimates; lines are 95% credible intervals. The dashed line marks zero.

“There was a strong probability that this effect was greater than zero (88%), but only a 54% probability that the difference in effect was greater than small.”

Singer et al. · Discussion, Sub-analysis of body regions · full text

How to read the result

Start with the plain picture. Without a comparison group, the pooled gains looked similar across rest lengths: short 0.48 (95% CrI 0.19–0.81) and longer 0.56 (95% CrI 0.24–0.86). Split four ways, the estimates were short 0.47, intermediate 0.65, long 0.55, and very long 0.50 (Results, Figs. 2–3). The authors read these as medium to large gains, whatever the rest length.

The direct comparisons are where the small edge shows up. A multivariate model that allowed for links between body sites gave arm 0.11, thigh 0.16, and whole body 0.03, all leaning toward longer rest. In the network meta-analysis, very long rest ranked highest for the thigh (SUCRA 0.64 vs 0.18 for short). The authors say that result was highly uncertain, and the U-shaped pattern in the medians “casts further doubt on the veracity of the finding.”

“The current evidence remains equivocal as to whether resting more than 90 s between sets further enhances hypertrophic adaptations.”

Singer et al. · Conclusion · full text

Why would longer rest help at all? The authors point to volume load. In one included study (Longo et al.), quadriceps cross-sectional area rose 13.1% with 180 s rest vs 6.8% with 60 s. Average reps across 3 sets were 16.1 vs 9.8. When extra sets were added to equate volume load, growth was similar.

“Potential beneficial effects of rest periods greater than 60 s on muscle hypertrophy may be attributable to preservation of volume load during a training session.”

Singer et al. · Discussion, Rest interval duration and volume load · full text

Training to failure did not change the picture. For the thigh, studies that trained to failure gave 0.31 (95% CrI −0.03 to 0.61) and non-failure studies gave 0.27 (95% CrI −0.02 to 0.51). In untrained participants only, the estimates were thigh 0.17, arm 0.02, and whole body −0.05.

The authors note that their result does not match the National Strength and Conditioning Association’s 30–90 s rest recommendation for hypertrophy, and they say current guidelines “warrant reconsideration.”

What this doesn't tell us

The evidence base is small: 9 studies, 19 measurements, and only 3 studies with whole-body data. Results varied a lot between studies. Most participants were untrained and young, with one study of older men. There were too few studies on trained lifters to analyze them separately.

“Unfortunately, there was insufficient data to subanalyze results on trained lifters, precluding our ability to further generalize this claim.”

Singer et al. · Discussion, Sub-analysis of participant training status · full text

The studies lasted 5 to 10 weeks at moderate set volumes, so higher volumes and longer programs are untested. The authors note that differences might add up over longer time frames. No study measured torso muscles such as the pectorals, latissimus dorsi, or deltoids. Exercise choice varied a lot. Whole-body results came from fat-free mass estimates (DXA, BIA, hydrodensitometry), which the authors say should be read with caution. The networks had no loops, so consistency checks were not run. Strength was not pooled. Study quality on the SMART-LD scale averaged 15 out of 20 (range 12–17).

One author (BJS) formerly served on the scientific advisory board of Tonal Corporation, a fitness equipment maker. The authors report no funding for this paper.

How to apply it

If you rest 60 s or less, this paper still shows muscle growth with short rests. If you rest longer, the direct comparisons lean slightly your way for arms and thighs, but the credible intervals cross zero.

This is my opinion, not advice. If I were in your spot and muscle size was the goal, I would rest long enough between sets that my reps don’t drop off sharply, rather than holding to a strict 60-second limit.

Sources

Source: Singer et al., Front Sports Act Living 2024; 9 studies, 5 to 10 weeks each. DOI 10.3389/fspor.2024.1429789.

  1. StudySinger A, Wolf M, Generoso L, Arias E, Delcastillo K, Echevarria E, Martinez A, Androulakis Korakakis P, Refalo MC, Swinton PA, Schoenfeld BJ. Give it a rest: a systematic review with Bayesian meta-analysis on the effect of inter-set rest interval duration on muscle hypertrophy. Frontiers in Sports and Active Living. 2024;6:1429789.
    DOI: 10.3389/fspor.2024.1429789 · Full text (PMC) · Publisher full text (CC BY)

This article explains research for education. It isn't medical advice.